Our Pastor

Pastor Caley was raised in Mansfield, Ohio. Following his high school graduation, he enlisted in the U.S. Army as a Combat Medic. His military service took him to Germany and New Mexico, and in 2008, he was deployed to Iraq. It was during this deployment that Pastor Caley came to trust Jesus Christ as his personal Savior.

In 2015, Pastor Caley answered God’s call to preach. He enrolled at Massillon Baptist College and graduated in 2018. Shortly thereafter, he entered full-time ministry as an assistant pastor at Cornerstone Baptist Church in Las Cruces, New Mexico. In 2022, the Lord led Pastor Caley and his family back to Ohio, where he continued to serve faithfully—both as an assistant pastor and by providing pulpit supply to churches in the surrounding area.

On April 1, 2025, God brought Pastor Caley to Old Paths Baptist Church. He and his wife share a deep love for the Bucyrus community and the surrounding region. They eagerly anticipate the great things God has in store for the people of Old Paths Baptist Church.